Thanksgiving specials · Preorders now open

Something sweet for
your holiday table.

Traditional favorites and specialty desserts, made with love at Alfonso’s.

PICKUP THANKSGIVING WEEK
November 24–26

Shop Thanksgiving specials ↗

Whole pumpkin, brown butter pecan and apple crumb pies arranged on an autumn table

Our bread. Your favorite sandwich.✦Specialty cakes for every occasion✦Fresh from our kitchen

Make it a lunch date

Meet your new
usual.

The Italian classic

The Godfather

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, roasted red pepper, lettuce, creamy house Italian & herb mayo.

Roasted tomato & burrata

La Caprese

Roasted tomato, burrata, pesto, parmesan, lettuce, creamy house Italian & balsamic drizzle.

Chicken salad with red grapes on a flaky croissant

A bakery lunch

Italian Chicken Salad

Pulled chicken, mayo, red grapes, celery, Italian herbs & lettuce.

Choose your bread: 8″ hoagie $9 · Focaccia $11 · Croissant $8 · 12″ hoagie $13.

Alfonso’s chocolate drip cake with piped frosting and chocolate decorations

Alfonso’s strawberry layer cake topped with strawberries and cream

Make their day

Good occasions.
Great cakes.

From a birthday favorite to a specialty cake for the whole table. Pick your flavor, size and icing, and tell us what you’re celebrating.

Tiramisu · Cannoli Cake · Dark Chocolate Mousse
Black Forest · Strawberry Cheesecake · Carrot Cake

Round cakes · Sheet cakes
Cupcakes: $30/dozen · Filled cupcakes: $38/dozen

We’ll confirm availability, pricing and pickup details with you.

There’s always room for a little sweet

Fresh bread.
Cannoli.
Daily discoveries.

Stop by for our daily breads and cannoli, and see what’s in the dessert case. Our rotating pastries and desserts mean there’s something new to discover.

Have your heart set on something?
Order desserts at least 48 hours ahead. Same-day dessert selection varies and items may sell out.

Call to order ahead ↗

Assortment of fruit-filled and iced pastries from Alfonso’s bakery

Bring everyone to the table

We’ll handle the food.

Sandwich trays, boxed lunches, family-style Italian entrées and desserts for office lunches, gatherings and celebrations.

View catering menu

Sandwich trays & boxed lunches

See our lunch menu for sandwich descriptions.

Small sandwich tray: $75; Feeds 8–10
Large sandwich tray: $135; Feeds 16–20
Standard boxed lunch: $15 per person; Sandwich, chips and cookie
Deluxe boxed lunch: $18 per person; Sandwich, deli side, mini cannoli and drink

Family-style entrées

Each tray feeds 6–9 and includes garlic bread.

Pasta Marinara: $42; Penne, linguine or angel hair with housemade marinara
Capellini Pomodoro: $48; Angel hair, stewed tomatoes, fresh basil, parmesan, olive oil and garlic
Stuffed Manicotti: $50; Spinach and ricotta filling, baked with marinara and mozzarella
Lasagna Classico: $65; Pasta, parmesan, mozzarella, ricotta and homemade meat sauce
Baked Ziti: $55; Ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan and marinara
Penne with Meatball & Sausage: $60; Marinara, housemade meatballs and Italian sausage
Chicken Parmesan: $70; Breaded chicken, mozzarella and marinara over pasta

Salads & sides

Each order feeds 10–15. Deli sides also available by the pint or half pint.

Italian Pasta Salad: $40
Pesto Orzo Salad: $40
Garden Salad: $35
Caesar Salad: $35
Broccoli Salad: $35

Breads & pastries

Fresh from the bakery for your gathering.

Fresh Bread Box: $20; Feeds 8–10 · Add garlic bread for $10
Croissant Selection: $35; Feeds 8–10 · Plain and chocolate; add almond for $5
Morning Pastries: $55; Feeds 10–15 · Scones, muffins, cinnamon rolls and coffee cake

Something sweet

Two dozen pieces per order, except custom cakes.

Cupcakes: $60
Assorted Mini Desserts: $55
Mini Cannoli: $48
Assorted Cookies: $36
Custom Cake: From $45; See our celebration cake options; custom designs available

Please allow at least 48 hours’ notice. All online orders are for pickup. For questions, dietary needs or larger events, call (740) 300-5050. Chafing dishes available upon request.

Come hungry. Leave happy.

See you at
Alfonso’s.

Find us

19 W. Columbus Street
Nelsonville, Ohio 45764

Get directions ↗

Stop in

Tuesday–Saturday
11:00 AM–5:00 PM
Sunday & Monday: closed

(740) 300-5050 ↗

Something sweet for
your holiday table.